
When Anthony Equale arrived at his apartment two days before college started, he wasn't alone. Mindy Horwitz was there, too — with his glassware she'd been storing for the summer and a four-pack of his favorite sugar-free energy drinks as a surprise.
Horwitz, 56, has taken to calling Equale "her very independent son." They are not related. His parents, who live in Houston, pay her about $1,600 a year for unlimited support while he attends Washington University in St. Louis. She bakes him homemade challah. She picks up his prescriptions. She coordinated with the bedbug exterminator. She sat with him in the emergency room. When she text his parents, she sends photos.
This is MindyKnows, one of a growing number of companies offering what amounts to a local surrogate parent for college students whose actual parents live far away. A New York Times investigation published last week found the industry quietly expanding across college towns — companies like The Bama Mama in Alabama, The GA Mom in Georgia, and Campus Mom in Texas — each staffed by local women who have become, for a fee, the presence parents can't provide in person.
What These Services Actually Do
The specific offerings vary but share common logic. Campus Mom offers "holistic wellness check-ins," laundry services, and — notably — sorority recruitment support packages. Carrie Eckhardt, the Bama Mama, will clean students' dorm rooms and check in with parents if they haven't heard from their child in a few days. She'll "pop in and say hi, and take a picture and send it to their mom."
When one parent told Eckhardt her daughter seemed to be going out to bars every night, but was actually staying in, Eckhardt assembled a "stay-in basket" — her daughter's favorite ice cream, cookie, and socks — to celebrate the decision.
Horwitz's unlimited package at Washington University costs $525 a year. MindyKnows has since expanded to nine other campuses — Northwestern, the University of Florida, UCLA — each with its own "Mindy" and price structure. She has also inspired off-shoots including Campus Mom.
"It's like having your mom's best friend live here," one college student told the Times. "My mom trusts you, but I also won't get yelled at."
Why This Is Happening Now

The industry's founders describe a specific shift: this generation of parents is more involved in their children's daily college life than any previous cohort, and when they can't be present, they want someone who can be a stand-in.
"When I came to college in 1998, my parents dropped me off on a Saturday and were gone," said Monteigne Long, co-founder of Campus Mom. "Parents are staying much more tuned in and connected with their students' college experience than they have in the past. When they can't be here, they want someone who can be that stand-in for them."
The services don't frame themselves as helicoptering. They frame themselves as support infrastructure — analogous to the informal networks that were always available to students who grew up where their college was, and now available for a fee to students from elsewhere.
Hamid Haidari, a client of Horwitz's, described it directly: "It's not a DoorDasher. It's like a surrogacy."
What Experts Think
Sociologists and developmental psychologists are more ambivalent than the families paying for these services.
Annette Lareau, a sociologist at the University of Pennsylvania who studies family life, told the Times she could see advantages for both parents and students — particularly for time-pressed mothers. And students clearly reap short-term benefits.
Her concern: whether young adults learn to rely on themselves or their peers when this much support is available. Larry Nelson, a professor of human development at Brigham Young University, drew a specific line: "There's nothing wrong with a care package. But as soon as anything crosses the line into doing it for them, that's where it gets problematic."
The founders disagree. Horwitz frames her work as making "the world a little gentler." Karen Allen, co-founder of Campus Mom, makes a practical argument: if she handles the laundry, the student can focus on class.
The Question Nobody Has Agreed On

The debate isn't really about whether these services are kind or helpful. They clearly are, for the students and parents involved. The debate is about what they might be doing to the larger project of college.
College has historically been understood as the transition from dependence to independence — the years when young adults learn to manage their own lives, not just their academics. Research on this transition consistently shows that navigating difficulty without parental intervention is part of how that development happens. Whether having a surrogate parent available for $525 a year changes the nature of that transition — or simply provides the safety net that most human development has always required — is the question these companies, knowingly or not, are testing at scale.














